Law

Protection of historical memory as an institution of constitutional law: Russian and foreign experience

Introduction. Identifi cation and analysis of factors infl uencing the transformation of the main institutions of constitutional law, the emergence and development of new constitutional and legal institutions are considered to be an urgent problem for the science of constitutional law. One of the dynamically developing institutions of constitutional law is, in our opinion, the protection of historical memory. The article uses formal legal, historical and comparative methods. Their application will allow for a comprehensive study of the constitutionalization of state memorial policy in Russia and abroad. Theoretical analysis. The protection of historical memory is a multi-component constitutional and legal institution that includes at least three levels: creation and consolidation of the state memorial concept (national image of history); preservation of historical heritage; protection of historical memory from encroachments and distortion. The authors study them in more detail, fi rst, by examining constitutional law of foreign states, and, then, by looking at the constitutional law of the Russian Federation. Empirical analysis.The research into constitutional and legal acts of foreign countries makes it possible to identify a steady tendency towards increasing social and political signifi cance of understanding one’s own national history, which contributes to the formation of a constitutional and legal institution for the protection of historical memory in many foreign countries. Legislation aimed at protecting historical memory was gradually being formed in Russia, including both measures of positive legal regulation and prohibitions on publicly challenging historical facts related to the Second World War. The task of developing a unifi ed political and legal concept of the national image of history and its constitutional and legal legalization turned out to be more diffi cult. Results.The establishment of the state memorial concept at the constitutional level is aimed at solving the tasks of determining the axiological foundations of development of society, formation of national identity, preservation of cultural identity and spiritual and informational sovereignty. The high social signifi cance of regulated public relations, their relative isolation and internal structural unity give reason to conclude that a new constitutional and legal institution for the protection of historical memory is being formed. This process is typical of both Russia and foreign countries. The controversial issues of the formation of this institution are related to its relationship with the already established principles and institutions of constitutional law.

Conceptual foundations of the Western communicative theory of law: Nicholas Luhmann

Introduction. The article deals with the theory of law by Nicholas Luhmann as one of the most important conceptual and methodological sources of Western communicative theories of law developed in the context of post-metaphysical thinking in social theory. Theoretical analysis. In the social system of Luhmann, communication communicates, so the concept of Luhmann belongs to the number of non-subjective ones. The legal system in this concept is formed by the diff erentiation of communications, thanks to which a legal co de arises. On its basis, specifi c communications are redefi ned, being included in the legal system. The function of the legal subsystem is to stabilize other subsystems by normalizing the expectations of counterparties and “monitoring” all subsystems. Empirical analysis. Luhmann shows that the justifi cation of law within law is impossible due to the paradox of self-application – law cannot determine whether it is itself a law. The logical paradoxicity of law does not cancel its functionality, since the basis of law is transcendent and is brought into the political system. Results.The Luhmann model of autopoiesis is not correlated with usnaturalism, since it is focused on the processes of social self-organization. It refl ects the classical explanatory schemes traditional for legal positivism, since positivization is ultimately subordinated to the transcendent political basis of law.

Ensuring the environmental rights of Russian citizens is a priority direction of the state’s environmental policy

Introduction. Decent and safe life and activities of Russian citizens can only be possible in the favorable environment. The constitutional and legal guarantee in this area is the consolidation of the environmental rights of Russian citizens as a constitutional value, and its provision is a priority task of the state and, accordingly, the most important direction of the implemented environmental policy. Theoretical analysis. The author determines the constitutional and legal content of environmental rights of Russian citizens, reveals their signifi cance for citizens and peoples living on the territory of Russia, identifi es trends, prospects and problems of their implementation and development, the role of public authorities in this process. Empirical analysis. The researcher claims that the right of citizens to participate in the management of state aff airs in the environmental sphere is implemented in various forms, of which an environmental referendum should be recognized the most eff ective, since its results are binding on public authorities. Despite this, environmental referendums are not often held. The reasons for this are, on the one hand, the unwillingness of the authorities to listen to the opinion of the population when delivering commercially successful projects, on the other hand, the complexity of the legally established procedure for holding a referendum. Results. It is proved that the right to the favorable environment is the main comprehensive constitutional environmental right, with other constitutional environmental rights being the means of its implementation, or restoration in case of violation. It is concluded that the problems associated with the realization of human rights arise from imperfections in the fi eld of law-making, law enforcement, as well as systemic problems of the state structure of Russia. It is pointed out that there is a need to develop state environmental policy in terms of strengthening legal, organizational and other measures aimed at more eff ective implementation of environmental rights of Russian citizens.

Theoretical and Practical Issues of the Hearing with Videoconferencing Systems

The persons involved in the case have the right to participate in arbitration Russia remotely using videoconferencing systems (VCS) according to the Federal Law dated 27.07.2010 № 228-FZ. This article examines a number of problems in the implementation of this law. Theoretical analysis. The author substantiate of independence of the Institute «hearing by VCS». We investigate the controversial moments of break and deposition hearing, which is conducted with IT-technology. We give a number of practical recommendations on the content of a pleading for video conferencing, and theoretical analysis of Part 1 of Article 153.1 of the Arbitration Procedure Code (APC) in respect of the persons entitled to file such a petition. The author proposes to amend to the paragraph 2 of Part 2 of Article 64 of the APC on the list of admissible evidence in the hearing via VCS. Conclusions. The need to consolidate the common rules for the arbitration courts in Russia hearings by VCS. The author proposes a definition of «hearing with videoconferencing systems».

Complex Institutions in the Law System of the Russian Federation

Law system has a complicated formation caused by several external and internal reasons. In actual conditions of intensive development and transformation of the public relations the law can not remain static. Its structure changes permanently. These changes not always are visible, caused first of all by new structure elements. More often such changes happen on the functional level of elements’ interaction. Methods. Methodological basis of the research is an internal interconnected complex of knowledge methods: system-structured, functional, logical. The basic method is materialistic dialectics, which allowed the author to investigate complex formations in connection and interdependence with other components of the law system and with the subject of their legal regulation. Results. The author emphasizes 3 principal features of complex structure community. Organizational feature is connected with external display of the complexity of the structure element of the law system. This feature allows to reveal a potential complex law formation, but is not an obligatory one. The idea of the organization feature consists in the following: the norms of one law branch are fixed in a legal act being a source of another law branch. The second feature of a complex formation is its subject of legal regulation, which as a rule matches with the subject of legal regulation of a particular law branch, adopting a legal norm from another law branch. An exclusion is the law communities being in process of formation, isolation (in transformation from complex internal branch institution to a separate law branch). The third feature of the complex formation is a reservation of branch attribution of adopted norms, which displays as in reservation of juridical construction of legal norm, identity of legal construction, and internally – in identity of regulative action.

Internet in the Objective Field of Legal Science: Problems of Theory

The article deals with the formation of the theoretical Internet model in Russian legal science, it also discusses the implementation of communicative approach to the Internet law methodology. Results. In our opinion, the operationalization of the idealized object of the Internet is formed on the basis of its technical artifact properties. Russian information law methodologists ignore social aspects of the Internet. The current situation needs methodological adjustments, that will let the Internet to be considered as the part of the social reality and make the nature of the Internet legal relationships comprehensible. Discussion. Social aspects of the Internet need to be fixed at the theoretical level. The Internet has the ability to be a tool of any legal relationship establishment. Thus it will be appropriate to use the knowledge about models and types of Internet communication, accumulated be the communication science.

Competition for International and National Labor Law as One of the Factors of Decent Work

Correction of national labor legislation according to the international labor legislation is an important step in overcoming the problems associated with the provision of decent work in Russia. Inaccurate translation, poor regulations, untimely introduction of changes lead to competition for international and Russian labor law. Results. Analysis of the Russian and international labor law rules competition has shown that it is a common phenomenon in the modern legal reality. To eliminate the competition between national labor standards and international law when national legislation imposing more extensive guarantees for workers compared to the norms of international law, it is necessary to amend Article 10 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation. Conclusions. Elimination of competition between the norms of national and international labor law is necessary and helps to create optimal conditions for the regulation of labor relations and directly connected to labor relations, the uniformity of enforcement. Non-compliance of the rules affects important aspects of labor law: the right to form trade unions, to strike, prohibition of discrimination, wages and others. Panacea for the elimination of the labor law rules competition is an analysis of the existing rules, changes in the law and improving the quality of regulations.

Political and Legal Aspects of Participation of Institute of Russian Presidential Envoy in Realization of State Awarding Policy

The article of O. Kokurina is dedicated to actual problem of participation of institute of Russian Presidential Envoy in realization of state awarding policy. Object. Main point of article is to analyze political and legal factors that determine evolution of participation of institute of Russian Presidential Envoy in realization of state awarding policy, research this policy and exploring its directions. Results. Author discovers roots of modern award policy, its federal and regional components. Article contains empirical and formal and logical analysis of legal base of regulation of awarding policy. This point allows tracing the most essential political and legal particularities of status of Russian Presidential Envoy in sphere of state awarding policy. Moreover, author concludes about identity of role of Russian Presidential Envoy in realization of state awarding policy and its priorities. Conclusions. In conclusion author deduces about status of awarding policy and positive role of changes in legal acts that regulates it. Beyond that, in article underlines sufficiency and effectiveness of seals of institute of Russian Presidential Envoy in federal districts that was developed and is based on existing traditions of organization of federal government. In this case of realization of awarding policy special attention is pay to interaction between Presidential Envoy with regional governments and also to HR and awarding state policy that underlines its value as autonomy and multi aspect branch of modern state policy.

Key Tasks and Activities of Military Justice in the Period of Martial Law in the Territory of Ukraine (1941–1942)

Given the current challenges and threats to national security, including armed conflicts near the borders of Ukraine, the study of the historical experience of the organization, regulation and activities of the military justice system with the onset of the special period of wartime became actual. Within the specified context study of these issues in a rather difficult period of transition from peacetime to wartime in Ukrainian territory on the beginning of the Great Patriotic War and the occupation of the territory of the USSR by troops of Nazi Germany (1941–1942) is noteworthy. At the same time, the specified experience can be useful during the reformation period the law enforcement system of Ukraine. Results. The article outlines the main objectives and directions of activity of the military justice system in a special period of martial law in the territory of Ukraine. Conclusion. Since the beginning of the war the military courts were entitled to consider not only the cases involving crimes of military, but also civilians and prisoners of war and foreigners. In legal documents, that somehow regulated the activities of military justice system, demands were made for conducting a ruthless struggle against disorganizers of the rear, deserters, panic-mongers, disseminators of rumors, the elimination of spies, saboteurs and enemy parachutists, neutralizing of dangerous individuals, the implementation of strict control of suspicious groups of citizens and maintenance of revolutionary order and discipline. In addition, almost all decision-making decrees required to use fast and balanced approach to the establishment of penalties for offenses, while strictly adhere to the provisions of existing laws and guidance documents.

Child’s Rights on Family Care

 The family institution is a complex social phenomenon, which experienced the terminological and structural transformation. In modern society the requirements increase to the quality of childcare and parents are imposed more obligations towards them. The right of the child on family care is an essential right of the child because the family care plays an important role in the physical and emotional development of children. The state should support and strengthen the family, create conditions for a child’s upbringing in the family, and promote family values. Theoretical analysis. In the article the family care is viewed from different perspectives; also a deep analysis of its legal interpretation is made. In addition to that, the constitutional provisions and rules of family law, as well as a new law «On Education in the Russian Federation», which is based on the principles of family care are interpreted. The right of the child on family care is represented as a complex subjective right, including authority to know their parents and live with them, the right to be cared by biological parents, the right on health and physical development, the right on financial support and well-being. Results. The result of the article is a proposal to improve the legislation of the Russian Federation on the issue of childcare in the following areas: the public control over the rights of children to live and grow up in a family; the adoption of the law on prevention from child abuse and neglect; the priority of family care for orphans and children left without parental care; the adoption of a new federal law on the rights of the child and bringing them into line with the current federal and regional Russian legislation.

Pages